VOAG Catalog Entry TopQuadrant attribution TopQuadrant, Inc. http://www.topquadrant.com Ralph Hodgson, TopQuadrant, Inc. TopQuadrant Logo 613 x 150 TopQuadrant's logo - diamond with company name to the right 613 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/logos/TQ_logo_C_2009_SM_print.jpg 150 title VOAG stands for "Vocabulary Of Attribution and Governance". The ontology is intended to specify licensing, attribution, provenance and governance of an ontology. VOAG captures many common license types and their restrictions. Where a license requires attribution, VOAG provides resources that allow the attribution should be made. Provenance is defined in terms of source and pedigree. A miminal model of governance is provided based on how issues, releases and changes are managed. VOAG does not import, but makes uses of some concepts from VOID (http://vocab.deri.ie/void), notably void:Dataset. voag VOAG subject Provides a schema for intellectual capital rights, attribution and governance. Uses the PROVO ontology for provenance. Typical use of the ontology is to refer to its resources, as opposed to importing the ontology. Ralph Hodgson Licensing, Attribution and Governance 1.0 Vocabulary Of Attribution and Governance 2011-01-31T10:00:00 2012-11-01 http://voag.linkedmodel.org/1.0/owl/schema/voag http://voag.linkedmodel.org/voag Vocabulary Of Attribution and Governance Governance Process A "Process". Icon A logo of some kind Creative Commons Prohibition something you may be asked not to do Publication Status 1 1 Party Priority value Product logo Product logo is used for products, solutions, etc. Issue Resolution Process A "Governance Process". Attribution logo Creative commons jurisdiction Creative Commons Jurisdiction the legal jurisdiction of a license Requirement An action that may or may not be requested of you an action that may or may not be requested of you Non-Concurrence Event A "Governance Event". Deletion Event A "Archival Event". Governed service 1 1 Qualifier Confidentiality level An enumerated codelist for values thath pertain to the security of a set of resources, or a resource. In 'lmc' an ontology can carry a property to denote its confidentiality. Change type Change Type provides an indicator for how an artifact has or will change in the future. This indicator is important to understanding the stability of an ontology. Vocab graph 1 Document 0 description 1 1 1 1 Pedigree The origin or source of something. The primary purpose of provenance is to capture the time, place, and if appropriate the person responsible, for the creation, production or provisioning of some information object. 1 Pedigree captures aspects of an artifact that have to do with maturity, quality, salience, and accredidation. 1 1 Rejection Event A "Governance Event". Schema graph 1 Creative commons work Creative Commons Work A potentially copyrightable work Governance Event A "Governance Event". Retreival Event A "Archival Event". Approval Event A "Governance Event". 1 A set of RDF triples in an ontology graph specified according to VOAG. 1 1 1 1 1 1 Graph 1 1 1 1 1 Provenance The origin or source of something. The primary purpose of provenance is to capture the time, place, and if appropriate the person responsible, for the creation, production or provisioning of some information object. 0 Provenance specifies the origin or source of some artifact. The primary purpose of provenance is to capture the time, place, and if appropriate the person responsible, for the creation, production or provisioning of The artifact. Provenance also captures a record of how a version may have been superceded by another version of the artifact. 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 captures issues such as raising of an issue related to a particular entity in a registry Issue 1 Standard An industry, de facto or de jure standard Metadata Enumerated value The base class in LMC for enumerated values Administrative Event An event that is associated with the admistration aspect of governance. Typically these are curation events. Person 0 1 Organization Review A "Governance Event". 1 1 Process 1 License Model A License Model describes the licensing conditions associated with a software artifact. 1 1 An 'Attribution' specifies how credit should be given when citing the creators of a piece of work. Attribution must use the specified attribution text and optionally use logos that are provided in the attribution details below., with the names of points of contact. Attributed Source 1 1 1 The name, url and other details of an attribution. 1 1 1 Event 1 1 1 1 Approval Process A "Governance Process". 1 Governed Object 1 An abstract class for all governed entities 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 Service Logo Logo is ... Accredidation 1 Catalog An index to a set of resources 1 Governance is mainly concerned with how an artifact is provisioned and managed over its lifecycle. Governance also concerns the status tracking and processes that need to exist on information objects and services for a successful initiaitve, mission, program, or project. Such governance needs to outline the relationships between all internal and external groups involved, describe the proper flow of information regarding to all stakeholders, ensure the appropriate review of issues encountered and ensure that required approvals and direction are obtained at each appropriate stage. 1 1 1 1 is ITAR International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR) is a set of United States government regulations that control the export and import of defense-related articles and services on the United States Munitions List. These regulations implement the provisions of the Arms Export Control Act, and are described in Title 22 (Foreign Relations), Chapter I (Department of State), Subchapter M of the Code of Federal Regulations. The Department of State interprets and enforces ITAR. Its goal is to advance national strategic objectives and U.S. foreign policy via the trade controls. For practical purposes, ITAR regulations dictate that information and material pertaining to defense and military related technologies may only be shared with US Persons unless approval from the Department of State is received or a special exemption is used. 1 Governance 1 Figure An illustration of some kind. Assigned role Issue Status The status of an issue: "Closed", "Deferred", "Non issue", "Open", "Resolved". Organization logo A logo for an organization Creative Commons Permission An action that may or may not be allowed or desired Governance Role A "Role" with the following instance(s): "authorizer", "steward", "submitter". Concurrence event A Governance Event. VOID Dataset A set of RDF triples that are published, maintained or aggregated by a single provider. 1 1 1 1 Image Image is a class for figures, pictures, logos, and icons of various kinds Widely adopted Some adoption Early adoption Proposed Unknown maturity Experimental In development Maturity 1 Stakeholder Group A Stakeholder Group is a party of people who have common interests and concerns. Never Daily Weekly Bi-Weekly bi-weekly Monthly Bi monthly bi-monthly Quarterly Bi quarterly bi-quarterly Annually annual Uncertain frequency Change frequency 1 Designated Governance Role A "Assigned Role" with the following instance(s): "Assurer", "Project Management", "Resource & Process Policy", "Technical Definitions", "User", "Verifier". Change Management Process A "Governance Process". 1 1 Governance Protocol 1 1 1 3 Governance is used to mean the processes that need to exist for a successful initiaitve, mission, program, or project. Such governance needs to outline the relationships between all internal and external groups involved, describe the proper flow of information regarding to all stakeholders, ensure the appropriate review of issues encountered and ensure that required approvals and direction for a 'GovernedEntity' is obtained at each appropriate stage. reviewed by References to which parties review a data or information asset. has status gives concurrence for An object property that specifies what a party may need to give consent, in the form of agreement, either written or verbally for in the approval of some govenance concern. This is the inverse property of 'mayNeedConcurrenceFrom' and, as such, may be deprecated in the future. has issue A pointer to an issue that exists on a subject of interest. jurisdiction jurisdiction has stakeholder has applicable document A document that is of help to application of the subject matter. Documents include specifications, models, standards, guidelines, handbooks and other special publications. has provenance A pointer to a provenance record that details the source, version and time of some subject of interest. governs A super-property of governance properties: 'approves', 'gives concurrence for', 'reviews' and 'witness to'. accountable for An object property used in governance that refers a resource to the party that is accountable for it. has change management process An object property that specifies a process that is used for managing change in a 'Governance Protocol'. has pedigree A reference to a description about the pedigree of something. has change type obsoleted by priority more permissions supervised by wintnessed by source has governance event An event associated with governance processes. has approval process An object property that specifies a process that is used for approval in a 'Governance Protocol'. has issue resolution process has category permits permits prepared by has confidentiality An object property that specifies a level of confidentiality. Typicall the range of this property will be 'voag:Confidentiality'. frequency of change has accredidation has owner has identifier has reference document is governed by A pointer to who is responsible for the governance of some entity of interest. This is a two-way reference with the inverse property 'governs'. has steward A pointer to the person that is a curator. reviews legalcode related issue This property connects two issue events. Issues connected by this property must be about the same subject witness to submitted by has logo A property to reference an image that is used as a logo. has value has normative document has anticipated change type performed by disposition status An object propoert that denotes the state of a governance issue. has protocol A pointer to a record that holds governance information for one or more governed entities. Often governance can be shared across entities. instigated by has ontology architecture diagram is approved by References to which parties approve an entity. prohibits prohibits requires requires may need concurrence from An object property that specifies that a party may need to give consent, in the form of agreement, either written or verbally to the approval of some govenance concern. participant interest of A pointer to parties who have an interest in an entity. This is a two-way reference with the inverse property 'interestIn'. used by The property 'usedBy' is a general property to record a dependency. One use is in stating how a schema or a vocabulary is used by another ontology graph. has governance owns interest in has approval status An object property that referes to an enumerated value that denotes the state of an approval. normative reference approves An object property that specifies that a party governs the approval of a resource. instigating event owner has maturity has process A reference to a process description. image map use guidelines derived from documented at The property 'vaem:documentedAt' is intended for general use as the name implies. In some cases the property could have scalar values and in other cases may need to refer to a first class concept that holds more information about a documentation resource. For this reason, the type of this property is set as 'rdf:Property' and the property is rangeless. width Width is typically used to specify an image's width attribute. height Height is typically used to specify an image's height attribute. url of turtle file Used to refer to a Turtle (N3) representation of an ontology downloads subject intent normative URL subject title event date url for HTML proprietary A boolean flag to indicate if an information asset is propretary. image The property 'vaem:image' points to an image using a URL. usage url id url address of RDF file Used to refer to a an RDF XML representation of an ontology attribution text disposition used to connect to the text describing disposition of something, for example, a disposition of an issue release date caption A short description, typically used on a table or a figure. point of contact user ID is FOSS A boolean property to specify whether or not software is free or open source. Free and open-source software (F/OSS, FOSS) or free/libre/open-source software (FLOSS) is software that is liberally licensed to grant the right of users to use, study, change, and improve its design through the availability of its source code. curated graph URI The property 'voag:curatedGraphURI' provides a means to specify the base URI of the specific version of the onotlogy that is being documented. In each versioned graph the 'vaem:namespace' carries a URI without a version number. start date licence timestamp owned by end date superceded by A pointer to one or more 'GovernedEntities' that replace this entity. supercedes A pointer to one or more 'GovernedEntities' that are replaced by this entity. related to incompatible with compatible with Creative Commons Lesser Copyleft derivative works must be licensed under specified terms, with at least the same conditions as the original work; combinations with the work may be licensed under different terms TBD tbd deprecated on No governance specified Review review Unclassified Unclassified is not technically a "classification"; this is the default, and refers to information that can be released to individuals without a clearance (Level 0). Information that is unclassified is sometimes restricted in its dissemination as SBU or FOUO. For example, the "law enforcement bulletins" often reported by the U.S. media when United States Department of Homeland Security raises the U.S. terror threat level are usually classified as "U//LES" or "Unclassified - Law Enforcement Sensitive." This information is only supposed to be released to Law Enforcement groups (Sheriff, Police, etc.) Because the information is unclassified, however, it is sometimes released to the public as well. Information which is unclassified, but which the government does not believe should be subject to Freedom of Information Act requests is often classified as U//FOUO - "Unclassified - For Official Use Only". In addition to FOUO information, information can be categorized according to its availability to be distributed (Distribution D may only be released to approved Department of Defense and Government Contractor personnel). Also, the statement of NOFORN (meaning No Foreign Nationals) is applied to any information which may not be released to any non-US Citizen. NOFORN and Distribution statements are often used in conjunction with classified information or alone on SBU information. Documents subject to export controls have a specific warning to that effect. unclassified 3 2 Disapproved Issue VOAG Logo 180 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/logos/voag_logo_360x110.png 55 VOAG Logo Low priority low Authorizer authorizer Non-issue non-issue Draft Status draft Top secret "Top Secret" shall be applied to information, the unauthorized disclosure of which reasonably could be expected to cause exceptionally grave damage to the national security that the original classification authority is able to identify or describe [US Executive Order 12958]. topsecret 7 6 Final Status LinkedModel ICON 200 x 80 LinkedModel Logo 200 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/logos/linkedmodels-logo.gif 80 LinkedModel Standard ICON Closed closed No provenance specified Creative Commons Attribution Credit to be given to copyright holder and/or author Not Applicable na Refactoring change Steward steward No pedigree specified Turtle Icon 32 X 35 Turtle is a representation format for RDF/OWL. 32 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/icons/turtle_icon_32x35.jpg 35 Turtle ICON Creative Commons Notice copyright and license notices be kept intact High income nation use Creative Commons High Income Nation Use Use in a non-developing country Submitter submitter SPARQL ICON 80 X 15 SPARQL Standard 80 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/icons/sw-sparql-blue.png 15 SPARQL Standard ICON Creative Commons Commercial Use Exercising rights for commercial purposes Deferred deferred Interim Status interim Append change Open An issue with undetermined disposition, open Creative Commons Share Alike derivative works be licensed under the same terms or compatible terms as the original work RDF Icon 32 X 35 RDF Standard 32 http://www.linkedmodel.org/lib/lm/images/icons/rdf_w3c_icon.48.gif 35 RDF Standard ICON Sharing Creative Commons Sharing permits commercial derivatives, but only non-commercial distribution Restricted During and before World War II, the U.S. had a category of classified information called restricted, which was below confidential. The U.S. no longer has a restricted classification, but many other nations and NATO do. The U.S. treats "restricted" information it receives from other governments as confidential. The U.S. does use the term restricted data in a completely different way to refer to nuclear secrets. restricted 2 1 Modification change exclude Secret "Secret" shall be applied to information, the unauthorized disclosure of which reasonably could be expected to cause serious damage to the national security that the original classification authority is able to identify or describe [US Executive Order 12958]. secret 6 5 Documentation change Reproduction Creative Commons Reproduction making multiple copies Approved Issue approved Sensitive but Unclassified Sensitive but Unclassified (SBU) information should not be disclosed but is not national security information and cannot be classified according to Executive Order (EO)12958, as amended. These materials must be: properly marked, locked up when not under the supervision of an authorized person, and encrypted while in transit over a non-secure network. Some examples are: trade secrets, proprietary information, financial information, personnel and medical records, procurement-sensitive information, IT system security plans, contingency plans, audit logs (recordings of exceptions and other security-related events), vulnerability reports, incident reports and Personally Identifiable Information (PII). sbu 4 3 Medium priority medium Obsolete obsolete Unknown Status unknown No attribution specified Derivative works Creative Commons Derivative Works Distribution of derivative works Resolved resolved Creative Commons Copyleft http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/copyleft.html combined works must be licensed under specified terms, similar to those on the original work Copyleft is a general method for making a program (or other work) free, and requiring all modified and extended versions of the program to be free as well. The simplest way to make a program free software is to put it in the public domain, uncopyrighted. This allows people to share the program and their improvements, if they are so minded. But it also allows uncooperative people to convert the program into proprietary software. They can make changes, many or few, and distribute the result as a proprietary product. People who receive the program in that modified form do not have the freedom that the original author gave them; the middleman has stripped it away. In the GNU project, Copyleft says that anyone who redistributes the software, with or without changes, must pass along the freedom to further copy and change it. Copyleft guarantees that every user has freedom. High priority high Creative Commons Source Code Source code (the preferred form for making modifications) must be provided when exercising some rights granted by the license. None none 1 0 Distribution Creative Commons Distribution Creative Commons - distribution, public display, and publicly performance Creative Commons Attribution-Share Alike 3.0 United States License